Bouvard Substack · Nov 15, 2026
The Deferral of Violence-ism
10 min read · 2,193 words
That deferral is productive is constitutive of the originary hypothesis but it hasn’t been explored as thoroughly as it might. Deferral, on the face of it, is refraining from action rather than acting and so one might charge center study with passive and reverential, as opposed, e.g., to Nietzschean and other modes of thought that privilege initiative and the world-making capacity of humans. Center study was first of all distinguished from Generative Anthropology through the privileging of (in Eric Gans’s terms) “producer’s desire” over “consumer satisfaction,” which entailed a kind of critique of GA precisely for a kind of quietism. This doesn’t direct address the question of the generativity of deferral, though, as a kind of creative endeavor that will enable us to account for the design of any scene and the entire stack of scenes.
Deferral is a response to mimetic rivalry and imminent violence, which means it results from a study of the emergent scene and the conditions of converting grasping into gesture. This entails a kind of directorial stance, involving guiding and coordinating various actors on the scene, which is clearly constructive. This kind of scenic design lays the conditions for detecting less imminent violent trajectories and consequently setting up various blocks toward the return of the mimetic crisis. Ritual, which iterates, under controlled conditions, the entire sequence from crisis toward deferral, is precisely such a block. Ritual involves a great deal of building, the more so the more accumulated the power at the center and therefore the stakes of even partial breakdowns in order. Technology as scenic design, and descendent from ritual, creates further blocks or obstacles which are, in effect, means of organizing groups and setting further goals, the accomplishment of which will introduce further buffers making the return to cataclysmic violence even more distant.
The world can only open to you insofar as you have renounced, even if temporarily (but once you’ve done so temporarily…) possession of anything in it. We speak of deferral rather than renunciation, though, because eventually you have to take possession of some things. The originary hypothesis accounts for this in terms of the sparagmos and the ritual closing of the scene—in terms of center study, or in this case anthropomorphics, this means using the sign to guide possession, appropriation and consumption so that even these “baser” actions commemorate the deferral making them possible. This involves all the little rituals of daily life, perhaps more enduring (but never guaranteed) than explicitly liturgical rituals, like opening doors for another, stepping aside, waiting your turn, sharing a meal, and so on. Everything endearing and beautiful in such rituals, or in the commemoration of birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, and so in is a manifestation of deferral and the space it opens up for an unlimited range of gestures.
Architecture and design are equally products of deferral—these disciplines are ways of arranging interactions, of separating the place where you sleep and make love from the place where you eat and the place where you excrete, indoor activities from outdoor, distance from and proximity to, neighbors; where we conduct business from where we live and where we go to be entertained or to shop and experience museums and so on. All of these differentiations involve channeling desires and therefore potential rivalries and the possibility, however remote, of violence, into conventional and controlled avenues so that they can be enacted and resolved.
Boundaries and jurisdictions, which enable us to map the world and create ethnic and national differentiations are likewise results of deferral, requiring permissions, recognition of different rules governing different places, the need to learn distinct idioms, all descendants of the originary sign governing our approach to the central object. Warrior cultures are, if anything, even more dependent on the repeated issuance of signs of deferral, especially among the elites, those most prone to react to insult with violence and thereby requiring the most elaborate system of gestures, ritual exchanges, codes of honor, specific means of settling differences that can’t be reconciled peacefully, and so on.
You could not have a single idea or concept that was not a product of deferral—when you withdraw into yourself, filter out the surrounding “noise,” working out the possible implications of a particular set of formulations or formulas, you are resting upon the structures of deferral that enable you to distinguish “signal” (sign created reality) from “noise” (the interference of insufficiently deferred mimetic inclinations and “vibrations”) in the first place. And when you withdraw into yourself you are rehearsing being a participant on a disciplinary scene, whoever you take your interlocutors there to be, and if you’re genuinely capable of such withdrawal and sustained introspection it is because you can represent to yourself such interlocutors in some detail and accurately, which in turn means you have accessed the disciplinary scenes either institutionally or autodidactically through literature.
As you progress through a series of distinctions, leading to ever greater precision, you are sharpening and tightening that scene, multiplying the number of “objects” that can be pointed to, that can be treated as the “same.” The same goes for scientific inquiry and it will go for space or oceanic exploration as these are the projections of new scenes upon which a new sign and a new nomos can be created, and thereby a new distribution. The very creation of a surplus to be stored and distributed over time is evidence and the effect of deferral—we don’t need to fight over what’s on the table because there is more in the refrigerator and we can go to the store tomorrow.
Improving or repairing a tool or innovating a new technology is deferral, because here as well one is on an inherited and carefully curated scene which one is prolonging and sustaining by practicing the kinds of gestures that make work in a workshop or laboratory possible. (The phenomenological reflections of thinkers like Husserl and Heidegger would be drastically clarified if they had access to the concept of deferral which is also the origin of “Being.”)
Deferral brings the extraordinary rich array of mimetic activities into view. As soon as we abort our gesture of appropriation because we have gotten some glimpse of where that movement of appropriation might lead, we can examine that movement against the background of the gesture that arrested it, study it and redirect it. If we think in terms of deferral we don’t have to think in terms of “pressing” down—suppression and repression—but in terms of all the ways a simple deflection of a particular gesture might lead that gesture in a wholly unanticipated direction and towards a “spiral” of innovative mimetic contagion that allows for us to arrange ourselves in relation to each other in unprecedented ways.
Center Study (and in this we of course follow Eric Gans’s Generative Anthropology) is one of the few modes of reflection on the human that doesn’t posit a violent origin for the species. We can therefore consistently imagine a continual expansion of the frontier of deferral, creating “tabernacles” of expectations that make violence vanishingly likely. And we can do this without fantasizing the end of any possibility of violence, since we don’t anticipate the extirpation of mimesis as the motive force of our activity—to do so would be to eliminate all pedagogy as well and to make humans incomprehensible. We can therefore retrench when necessary, when some bulwark, some part of the stack serving as an advance warning system against some encroachment of violent inclinations, is weakened or breached.
And this expansion and retrenchment of the boundaries of civilization is enormously creative—in fact, this is the source of those architectural and design differentiations discussed earlier. As a potential rival to others who are in turn my rival, I construct means of detection and measurement to assess the other’s approach to whatever counts on the scene as a shared object (or perhaps it’s better to say “fount,” in the sense of a source of goods, rather than “object”—and this questioning of terminology is itself an act of deferral, an attempt to maintain the space of Center Study against the various “devil’s advocates” [little antichrists?] it might attract) and these means of detection and measurement get inscribed in buildings and roads and habits and divisions of labor and architectural segregation (prisons) and eventually surveillance technologies that operate algorithmically.
The Katechon is an icon of deferral (the “Restrainer”) and this would mean that figures like Satan and the Anti-Christ are “anti-deferral,” but that can’t be in any simple way because to be only and completely anti-deferral would mean being unintelligible and ineffectual. The use of language, even if just to say, “Kill Them All!” is an act of deferral, in the case of the sample statement here, regarding the imminent possibility of at least some of us killing each other. Add to this the assumption that the Anti-Christ comes disguised as the Redeemer and, presumably, Satan also come disguised as some kind of bearer of gifts, and we have an interesting problem on our hands: how do we distinguish a gesture of deferral from conversion of that gesture back into an expression of resentment?
The answer has to lie in the characterization of the Katechon as the true judge. Justice is a very ancient and fundamental mode of deferral and we might suspect those who call into question the possibility of justice (or see it as inherently fraudulent, a sheer power play, etc.) as being the very purveyors of the lack of restraint we’re looking for. The. “peace and safety” that Peter Thiel considers the idiom of the Anti-Christ should be distinguished not so much from innovation as from justice. Ensure justice and the innovation will come, because peaceful interaction will replace the various kinds of protection and extortion rackets that justice resists—it will become possible to imagine modes of cooperation beyond self-protection and preparing to attack before you become a victim.
(This is often how markets are described, and this is no coincidence, since markets are completely dependent on trusted arbiters.) Justice does not try to suppress risk in advance, providing only for liability in the aftermath which, of course, does create expectations but those expectations can be shaped rather than suppressed in the name of an emergency. Justice is self-evidently possible, as even those cynically denying would have to admit if they were asked whether they are genuinely incapable, under and conditions, of deciding a dispute between two parties without having an interest in either side prevailing.
Could anyone really deny that, either as a matter of basic maturity, or without indicting oneself of sociopathy? How about two children fighting over a toy? Are you really incapable of determining and enforcing a settlement that both might be unhappy with but could ultimately accept, and without taking one child’s side over the other? Do you really want to confess to such incapacity? That’s all justice is—both sides heard, both claims weighed, disinterest on the part of the judge, a verdict that neither side will be determined to overturn through violence. All of us do justice all the time. Institutionalizing justice faces formidable obstacles, but that says nothing about its possibility, which also lies in the lesser institutionalized forms it takes, like “blood money” as recompense for injury or death, which already involves the kind of measurement implicit in justice.
It seems we have identified the Anti-Christ and Satan—those who deny the possibility of justice, whether openly and explicitly or, more likely, insidiously and through insinuations. Our Anti-Christ doesn’t need to deny the possibility of justice in general—just the impossibility of justice in each and every case that happens to come up. Others will always try to cheat you, and the amorphous “powers that be” will let them get away with it (of course, “cheating” means nothing without some reference to justice, so the Anti-Christ testifies against himself); you need to get your own, by whatever means necessary, and I’m on your side, willing to help you.
That’s the voice of Satan. And “peace and safety” (especially “safety,” I would say) is an effective idiom for subverting justice—there is no recourse other than through submission to me. The hour is late, time to get on board, etc. And we can see the crippling of deferral in this stance—while you’re restraining yourselves others are seizing the fount, usurping the center, and so you better drop the hesitations and get with the team. “Peace and safety” makes enemies of every “belligerent” and source of “risk,” which, really can mean everyone, because who cannot be accused of upsetting the social order by doing things unscripted or unsanctified by the protecting authority?
Defending justice leaves you naked, willing to submit your testimony, even in advance of having any reason to trust the authority who will be taking it in this case. This is a distinction we can learn to make and learn to make in more complex forms, and that we could deliberate over—proof that someone wants justice is a willingness to hear new testimony. And all our imaginings of a revelation or apocalypse involve the triumph of justice and those imaginings are the surest source of discovery, invention and innovation.
The Deferral of Violence-ism — https://center.study/post/the-deferral-of-violence-ism