Skip to content

Concept

Mimesis

“My starting assumption is that humans are mimetic beings: we learn everything we learn by imitation.”

From the Archive

“Mimesis is obviously a very ancient concept, prominent in Plato and Aristotle, but as far as I know until Rene Girard it was never pursued all the way down—it’s one thing to say humans are mimetic beings, but it’s another to say that mimesis makes the human.”

“Mimesis is two-sided: first of all, it is unconscious and discovered (if at all) after fact, usually through some unpleasant revelation; on the other hand, more deliberately, it is a way of approaching others from the outside so as to take on their attributes and their power.”

“And this is the real problem of mimesis, and Girard’s great discovery—imitation leads to rivalry because we learn to desire from our models and must therefore ultimately desire the destruction and our replacement of those models.”

“Mimesis is an excellent foundation for talking about the human because it provides a minimal version of human sameness that immediately opens onto a vista of human difference.”

“What makes linguistic imitation different than imitation in the pursuit of limited resources (including resources limited because of mimesis) is that a sign or utterance can be different in being the same.”

“It is to Girard that we owe these insights; yet he neglects the quality of human mimesis that separates us from the higher animals: mimesis is not merely imitation, it is representation.”

Across the Corpus

How this idea is developed elsewhere in the archive, earliest to latest.

“People would far rather believe that they want to  sleep with their mother  and  kill their father  than admit that their desire imitates the desire of others and that their  resentment  of these others is the real source of their  aggression . By keeping these passions in the family, the Freudian system softens their impact. I hate X because he reminds me…”

“In order to account for formal mimesis, or linguistic representation, we have to allow as a logical and empirical necessity for the priority of behavioral mimesis–unformulated, instinctual, or genetic: we don’t yet know (1) –that humans share with the higher mammals from which we are descended. At stake here is our continuity with other living species, in…”

“Human mimesis does not need to change the genetic code to influence behavior, or desire itself, because relationships between human beings are mediated by the scene of representation. The disciple does not imitate the master’s desire as one imitates a physical gesture; this desire functions to sacralize its object. The fact that Girard has never…”

“Throw a piece of bread off the wharf and immediately seagulls swarm the morsel. Mimesis works. What makes human mimesis different? The difference is difference itself: i.e. , the arbitrariness of the relation between imitated gesture and the object it “points” to ( cf. my dog and the roast beef). In the originary scene, this gesture has to be motivated…”

“Some food would taste better than others, some potential mates be preferable to others, etc. But, absent mimesis, we wouldn’t want a particular “object of desire” more because we have been denied it, or because we imagine someone else enjoying it. And this also means that without mimesis we wouldn’t think in “non-pragmatic” ways about things, because what…”

“An domain that would greatly benefit by originary analysis is that of mimesis itself. When Girard wrote Mensonge romantique , his analyses of the structure of desire were above all attempts to make clear its mediated nature. The book’s epigraph from Scheler, L’homme possède ou un Dieu ou une idole , describes “mediation” as the sin of idolatry, but we…”

“I should say that I see no problem with “mimesis,” both because it is not a specifically human concept and because I see a fairly easy way to translate it (and its escalation into mimetic crisis) into the primes, indicating its universality: “Someone can say: ‘I see you do something.’ This person wants to do like this other someone. This person wants to…”

“Mimesis is central to our identity as humans. Aristotle observed long ago that humans are the most mimetic of animals. For Aristotle, our mimetic nature explains the delight we take in works of art that represent events or objects. He notes that we learn by imitation, and we enjoy learning new things (Aristotle 6-7). Aristotle was refuting Plato’s…”

“The prehistory of generative anthropology, beginning with René Girard’s Mensonge romantique et vérité romanesque in 1961 and its theory of mimetic desire, puts mimesis at the core of our theory of the human. And although natural scientists can discuss the physiological aspects of mimesis: “mirror neurons” and the rest, just as they can study the…”

“Unlike Derridean deconstruction, until recently so popular among academics, mimesis or imitation is something we can all understand. Mimesis is essential to all forms of intelligence, and particularly to the human. Aristotle’s remark that humans are the most mimetic of creatures was a profound anthropological observation—one that, had he been able to make…”

Key Texts

Related Concepts