“That the first sign—inaugurating the human—would be a sign of deferral is rich in consequences insofar as it defines representation as the deferral of violence and the human as that species which poses a greater danger to itself than is posed by any external threat.”
From the Archive
“A sign is the deferral of violence.”
““Deferral,” meanwhile, perfectly captures the position within the act itself, along with its fundamental contingency, between the convergence heading toward destruction and what will perhaps be no more than the mere delay of that tendency.”
“The origin of the human is not the concentration or the externalization of violence, but its deferral .”
“What this means is that extending the scene of deferral is not primarily a question of waiting longer to eat, or strike back, or enjoy anything.”
“Insofar as we use language, we participate in the deferral of violence; even more, though, we presuppose the subsistence of the entire history of such deferrals.”
“Language is not a simple sign of liberation from the animal state, of the passage from the realm of necessity to the realm of freedom ; it is in the first place a means of deferring mimetic violence .”
Across the Corpus
How this idea is developed elsewhere in the archive, earliest to latest.
“Hence, the title of my post is a “translation” of “representation is the deferral of violence.” A bit of violence is done to “rendering,” which I think is rarely used as a gerund, much less with the copula—indeed, it remains a bit of verbness in this formulation. A similar operation could, of course, be performed on “represent” as well, but “representing is…”
“Humanity presupposes the deferral of violence; society presupposes shared norms enhancing and regularizing the capacity to defer violence; civilization further presupposes entire zones of existence in which the deferral of violence can be taken for granted, which is to say that means of deferral and rules for their deployment, need not be posited, even…”
“But before the existence of linguistic paradigms, the originary object of deferral must have been the potential violence attendant on a worldly rather than a “symbolic” act. It is this aborted gesture of appropriation , designating the object but no longer directed at appropriating it, that we postulate as the first sign . This suspension of appropriative…”
“It is also the work of deferral, as what the center has to say always has to do with the detecting and diverting the various forms of mimetic violence. And the forms of mimetic violence themselves multiply and in some ways are strengthened as signs and institutions are fortified and attention is prolonged: each new social structure relies upon a new…”
“I’ve been limiting my discussions of media by assuming it is the sign and sign system that is the media while it is, in fact, the form of deferral created by that particular sign. It is the deferral created by the issuance of the sign that provides for the new form of sense and intellectual activity characteristic of engagement with that medium. Let’s take…”
“A sign is the deferral of violence. The first sign deferred imminent violence; subsequent signs may also do so, or they may defer intimations of merely possible violence, raising the threshold of what would count as a cause for violence. And not just violence in in general, but mimetically driven violence that would, if undeferred, consume all. So, in…”
“The value of such an account, though, lies in the need to hypothesize the sign being repeated and made memorable. Eventually the ritual would be moved to prior to the act of consumption, so as to prevent in advance the possibility that this time the scene might not play out in ideal form. The paradoxes of deferral we see on the originary scene are enduring…”
“(Maybe the “deferral of violation” is better—but “violation” often refers more specifically either to rape or to more commonplace transgressions.) Like, say, your twin brother stabbing you in the back as you’re about to confront a shared enemy. But this means that the “violence” in question doesn’t simply come before the sign, and the sign doesn’t just halt…”
“Think about taking a single sentence like, say, “representation is the deferral of violence” and simply reversing its terms: “violence is the deferral of representation.” We give ourselves a puzzle here—the new sentence doesn’t immediately make sense, but on a second look perhaps there’s something we could do with it, perhaps even in such a way as to add…”
“I said last week that I would like a more precise term for the specific kind of annihilatory violence that is imagined here. It might help to remember that Gans took the notion of “deferral” from Derrida’s “differance,” which includes both the word deferral and the word difference which, at bottom are the same word. So, let’s set aside “violence” for now,…”