Skip to content

Concept

Narrative

“It is now clear to me that the conversion of ritual/myth into practice/hypothesis implies the opposition to narrative, which is really the continuation of myth. Narrative is always sacrificial, regardless of the best efforts of its most sophisticated practitioners.”

From the Archive

“Originary analysis provides a simple explanation for the failure of attempts to define the “grammar” of narrative: narrative begins not with articulated language but with the originary sign. What makes storytelling a useful paradigm for culture in general is precisely the absence of any simple correspondence between the formal structures of language and the institutional structures of narrative.”

“But once we grant this, we must conceive the originary—and every subsequent—use of the sign as “narrative.” Narrativity requires nothing of the sign beyond its own inherent temporality. Narrative emerges when the time of the sign returns to the world as a model of the time of action.”

“Narrative is characterized by a provisional espousal of individual desire despite its ultimate incompatibility with sacred order, an identification that has its origin in the experience of originary firstness.”

“Narratives, by definition, have beginnings, middles and ends. They have characters, or agents—usually in some hierarchy of importance (main character, supporting character, etc.).”

“In the Homeric epics that are the ancestors of all Western fictional narratives, what ties the beginning to the end is resentment .”

“The ambiguity of narrative desire amounts to a tugging in two directions, insofar as we both desire and resist the ending.”

“So, what was once narrative becomes scenic intelligence.”

Across the Corpus

How this idea is developed elsewhere in the archive, earliest to latest.

“All culture is textual in that it is made up of representations that are virtually if not actually copresent. The distinction between oral and written culture is secondary. The “inscription” of the story in the mind is not as accurate as that of the text on paper, but its relationship to the linear time of telling is essentially the same: in either case,…”

“In the same manner, recent anthropological approaches present us with the paradox that narrative non-performance–the actual breakdown of conventional meaning–reveals the dynamic of narrative self-generation. Whether in Wolfgang Iser’s “literary anthropology” or Eric Gans’s “generative anthropology” the problematic evolutionary development of culture calls…”

“The second level of our research program is that of the empirical examination of esthetic experience. Humans obtain enjoyment from stories and may reasonably be said to have a need for them; all cultures engage in storytelling, from the level of communally accepted myth to that of ephemeral gossip. Positive anthropology finds it easy to conceive adaptive…”

“I should say at the outset that I am not good at telling stories. Finding the story-teller’s position too perilously hierarchical, I prefer to improvise an answer, interject a witticism, make up class lectures as I go along. Wary of generating narrative, I turn to theory to explain its dangers. This Chronicle is one of several stabs at an originary…”

“It is only with generative anthropology, the third generation of the linguistic turn, that the anthropological reality of language is taken into account. In Hegelian terms, if structuralism is the thesis, and post-structuralism, its antithesis, generative anthropology is the synthesis of these two positions, replacing the metaphysical reliance on…”

“This is the hypothetical scene on which human language originated and on which human language continues to be used. The scene of representation is that place in which a hypothesized generative set of circumstances produced the event of originary signification. Generative anthropology proposes that human beings are best understood not as grammatical subjects…”

“Yet nothing in this critique of narrative provides a new understanding of what narrative is . In the heyday of French semiology in the 1970s, considerable effort was expended in the search for the building-blocks of narrative, but the historical consensus seems to be that the attempt was unsuccessful. Barthes’ S/Z is an estimable but only partial…”

“It is Generative Anthropology (GA)’s ambition, not to synthesize the substance of these discourses, let alone to “inter-disciplinarize” them, but to trace them back to their originary roots and explain why they diverged, and why their diverse paths were in some sense necessary. In The Origin of Language (TOOL) I made a fundamental distinction between two…”

“Generative Anthropology has dealt both with the story and narration aspects of narrativity as derivations from the originary scene. In Originary Thinking and his “Originary Narrative” article, Eric Gans focuses on the story and traces what we perceive as its suspense-generating drive toward closure to the origin of signification, which gives birth to the…”

“Time is precious, and to devote time to signifying something beyond simply attempting to make use of it is to defer one’s worldly relationship to it and to everything else. As language users we of course take this for granted. The purpose of generative anthropology is to explain the necessity of this deferral in terms of the human need to avoid…”

Key Texts

Related Concepts