“I noticed that the Christian concept of the “Katechon,” or the restrainer of the AntiChrist, was a very near synonym to “deferral.””
From the Archive
“I was prompted to do so, in part, by reading Raphael Gross’s Carl Schmitt and the Jews: The “Jewish Question,” the Holocaust and German Legal Theory (a very good book, by the way), where I noticed that the Christian concept of the “Katechon,” or the restrainer of the AntiChrist, was a very near synonym to “deferral.” This makes it possible to further extend center study into new fields of inquiry, in this case not only Schmitt, but Peter Thiel’s studies of apocalypse, which makes regular use of this theological framing of politics. (While I have been familiar with the Katechon for some time, I think what jarred me into taking it more seriously was a point in Gross’s discussion where he uses the word “deferral” in describing Schmitt’s understanding of the term, and something clicked.)”
“the difference between pointing as singling out the victim for a lynching and pointing as an act of deferral, a substitute for the lynching (let’s say, the paraclete, or advocate, supplementing the katechon)”
“I’m not going to think theologically, but now I have a way of translating into anthropological idioms this theological framing which, it seems, Thiel has found no better “secular” alternative to.”
“Deferral is scenic creation, and language records the scenes upon which it has been operative while creating scenes within scenes upon which we can say “this is the same” in a new way.”
“So, to speak in sentences is to draw upon and issue lines of credit. The debt we owe to the center is a product of deferral, and the lines of credit issued are therefore tokenized deferrals.”
Across the Corpus
How this idea is developed elsewhere in the archive, earliest to latest.
“The “ fort/da d’où surgit toute nomination” opposes the significant object to its absence, just as the first ostensive name-of-God opposes the significant/sacred central object to the insignificant/profane periphery. The phenomenon of deferral , Derrida’s différance transferred from a metaphysical to an anthropological context, from its creator’s…”
“Derrida himself was too much of a snob to take an interest in GA, so we’ll never know what he might have thought of GA’s use of the “Derridean” term deferral , the English translation of différance . It is a bit artificial to divide between the Jewish and the Christian the metaphysical realm, which belongs to neither, but at the very least we can say that…”
“The declarative sentence encompasses in its “timeless” predication both the firstness and the deferral of the originary ostensive use of language. Instead of designating the center as an interdicted space in which violence is deferred, it takes this center, or “subject,” into itself, and attaches by predication a new “truth” about it that goes beyond the…”
“I am trying to develop a mode of political thinking that is not a political philosophy. A political philosophy, like any philosophy, has “first principles,” and then starts “deducing” secondary principles from the first one (freedom, consent, the will of the people, etc.) including justifications of monarchy in terms of such principles, like the monarch as…”
“But as we might expect, any speculations on these matters take us into a grey area between the originary hypothesis and historical evidence, a domain in which the hypothesis supplies only general principles. The point to retain is that the principle of deferral, as Derrida well understood from within the philosophical tradition, is a principle of…”
“The fact of contemplating the central object in the course of the event involves not simply being physically distant from it, but understanding this distance as the worldly expression of an interdictory sacred space surrounding the object which can be breached only by the group’s eventual common agreement to divide up the animal for consumption in a…”
“This post will be a synthesis and reframing of many of my previous discussions of language, prompted by the observation that I have never directly applied deferral to the analysis of language itself, in the form of analyzing and interpreting language in terms of modes, degrees and layers of deferral—something which, in the context of originary debt and…”
“Language is the apocalypse which, as is well known, is essentially synonymous with “revelation.” In theo-political terms, the idiom is the restrainer or Katechon. I’ve been constructing the Natural Semantic Primes as a kind of originary declarative layer over a more originary ostensive and imperative “substrate.” How we operate the declarative layer derives…”
“And this expansion and retrenchment of the boundaries of civilization is enormously creative—in fact, this is the source of those architectural and design differentiations discussed earlier. As a potential rival to others who are in turn my rival, I construct means of detection and measurement to assess the other’s approach to whatever counts on the scene…”
“Here are some dictionary provided synonyms for “defer”: postpone, put off, adjourn, delay, hold off, hold over, shelve, suspend, delay, hold in abeyance, stay, prorogue, pigeonhole, mothball. None of them quite get at how minimal “deferral” is, conceptually, and how central it therefore is to the specificity of the originary hypothesis, and to GA’s…”