Skip to content
Back
X / TwitterNov 08, 20262 min read

Bouvard on Sovereignty and Constitutional Factionalism

By Dennis Bouvard

The voter fraud issues are downstream of the illegal immigration issue, the NGO issue and the judiciary issue, or maybe they're all downstream of each other, because they are all part of the question of sovereignty. The only way I can think to solve this within the terms of the

constitution would be to retrieve perhaps the most radical and certainly the most forgetten conviction shared by the founders: the repudiation of factionalism. For them, this was based on a virtue based republicanlism and, of course, collapsed almost immediately. But maybe a ban

on factionalism can be be reframed and enforced on new theoretical and technological terms. (Of course, Madison wanted to play faction off against faction--that's been given a good try. Now we have fractal factionalism. Washington was the most adamantly anti-faction founder.)

A clarification of executive authority would be necessary, but more than anything else a trusted truth-bearing institution--what the universities and media are supposed to be but never have been and are less now than ever. There are sporadic attempts to create such spaces but

they get immediately swallowed into factionalism, because it can't just be a matter of immediately politically relevant facts, but a coherent, anthropologically and historically grounded understanding focused on sovereignty. And such an institution would have to defer any bid for

political influence and be ready to take a lot of slings and arrows while responding systematically and patiently to feedback. ("Grok is this true" reflects a desire for something like this.) Eventually everything anyone says publicly is recorded and retrievable and could be

measured against the sovereign truth. It would simply be impossible to depart from the sovereign truth without surrendering all authority and factionalism would become impossible because disagreements could readily to be submitted to sovereign judgment rather than festering and

congealing into factions. And a sovereign truth institution is something that can be founded at any time, pretty much regardless of political conditions, even if some conditions might make it harder to build. In the meantime it would provide training in governance and the

careers of its graduates would serve as tests of its reliability. And AI would be directed to its highest use, which is conducting searches across vast historical databases (digitzied humanity) for research projects we can only dimly imagine now.

@taimur_____ What you recommend has been done, albeit not by me--all that work has been uploaded (if that's the correct term) to AI. I agree with your assessment but, first, a lot of statements are not on the ledger--a lot has yet to be digitized; second, I won't need the kind of alignment

@taimur_____ until I or others scale up quite either through the formation of some kind of company or intensive research (hopefully also organized).

@taimur_____ It would depend on the company but in general I'd like to say the algorithms+the human judgment guiding them.

Bouvard on Sovereignty and Constitutional Factionalism — https://center.study/post/2119409097887920640

Dennis Bouvard publishes a new essay on Substack every two weeks. Subscribe ↗

@centerstudy_ on X ↗ · RSS · Lectures